Erika Lora, 35, came to the Hartung Drive resident’s front door, provided the name on the package and asked for it, Lt. Joseph Soto said.
The resident claimed the package – containing a new cellphone worth about $1,000 -- never arrived, Soto said.
She called police as the couple drove off in a car they’d parked in the homeowner’s driveway, he said.
Wyckoff police broadcast an alert, and Upper Saddle River police stopped the car a short time later, the lieutenant said.
Both Lora and Juan Carlos Lugo, 44, were charged with conspiring to receive stolen property. Both were released pending court hearings.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Rutherford and receive free news updates.